X-Git-Url: https://fleuret.org/cgi-bin/gitweb/gitweb.cgi?a=blobdiff_plain;ds=inline;f=README.txt;h=d5cf6d861245694c9fd2c2c4770486e762d949ae;hb=cdf7c042612ee3b7e5cc2277e82399693a3bf343;hp=d4cb93d405a81f0d3d3b6118ab06860f2953cb68;hpb=2175a87ad4304a97c63ac9cca6224d0c0b74c64e;p=culture.git

diff --git a/README.txt b/README.txt
index d4cb93d..d5cf6d8 100644
--- a/README.txt
+++ b/README.txt
@@ -1,17 +1,61 @@
 
-For the stack experiment:
+Trying to make GPTs build their own "culture".
 
-./main.py --task=stack
+Francois Fleuret
+Jun 21st, 2024
 
-Takes ~1h10min on a 4090.
+* Motivation
 
-For the arithmetic expressions experiments
+The original motivation of this experiment is the hypothesis that
+high-level cognition emerges from the competition among humans in the
+space of language and ideas.
 
-# 38M parameters / 250k samples
+More precisely, communicating agents try to out-do competitors by
+creating stuff that is smart but doable, e.g. some other agents get
+it, but not all. Then, that smart thing is added to the "culture",
+they all learn and get to understand it, and it repeats.
 
-./main.py --task=expr
+* Setup
 
-# 352M parameters / 2.5M samples, reaches 99.80% after 12 epochs, the
-  learning rate schedule is obviously terrible
+It starts with a "world model" that they got before they communicate,
+and from there, they try to "be smart" by proposing quizzes that can
+be solved but not by everybody.
 
-./main.py --task=expr --nb_blocks=48 --dim_model=1024 --nb_train_samples=2500000 --result_dir=results_expr_48b_d1024_2.5M
+There are 5 competing GPTs.
+
+The "world" is a 7x9 grid with three "birds" moving in a straight line
+and bouncing on the world's borders. It could be another "world", but
+this one has objectness and motion.
+
+Given a random world state, and the state after two iterations of
+birds moving, a "quiz" is to predict the second frame, given the
+first, or the opposite. The starting and ending states are chosen, by
+rejection, so that there is no occlusion.
+
+My home-baked GPT-37M trained with 250k solves this with ~99% success
+[to be verified with the new setup].
+
+At every iteration, we select the GPT with the lowest test accuracy,
+and run one epoch.
+
+If its test accuracy got higher than 97.5%, it will create new
+quizzes. To do so, it generates a large number of pairs of frames, and
+checks which ones of these quizzes are hard but not too hard, which
+means
+
+[THIS IS THE IMPORTANT BIT]:
+
+it can be solved, in both time directions, by all the other GPTs **but
+one**
+
+The both time directions is to avoid a simple type of quizzes which is
+simply to deal with noise in the first frame.
+
+The GPT generates 1000 of such quizzes, that are added to the
+"culture", i.e. the training set.
+
+We update the test accuracy of all the GPTs, and then we go to the
+next iteration.
+
+The hope is that interesting concepts emerge (connectivity, symmetry,
+interior/exterior, shape vocabulary, etc.)